Key facts
- Private wells are not regulated by EPA, so the owner is responsible for the safety of the water.EPA: Private Drinking Water Wells
- Shock chlorination kills bacteria after repairs, flooding or a positive coliform test, but it does not fix ongoing contamination.Minnesota Dept. of Health: Well Disinfection
- Common pressure switch settings are 30/50 psi and 40/60 psi.NGWA: WellOwner.org
What the job covers
A well pump swap is more than lifting one part out and dropping another in. The pump sits at the bottom of a steel or plastic casing, hanging on a drop pipe, with an electric cable running alongside. Everything in that string is reused or replaced as one job.
The crew also checks the parts that work with the pump: the pitless adapter at the top of the well, the pressure tank, the pressure switch and the wiring. A new pump on tired supporting parts often fails early.
The job step by step
- Confirm the pump is the problemA pro checks power, the pressure switch, the control box if you have one and the wire before pulling anything. Many no-water calls turn out to be a switch, capacitor or tripped breaker.
- Turn off powerThe pump breaker is switched off and locked or tagged so nobody turns it back on while the wire is open.
- Open the well and pull the stringThe well cap comes off, the drop pipe is disconnected at the pitless adapter, and the pump, pipe and cable are lifted out in sections with a puller or rig.
- Inspect everythingThe pipe, wire, splices, check valve and torque arrestor are looked over for wear, pinholes, scale or damage. Bad sections are replaced.
- Size and set the new pumpThe new pump must match the well depth, water level, yield and the house's flow needs. It is lowered on the pipe and set at the planned depth.
- Reconnect and flushPower and water lines are reconnected, the system is started, and the water is run until it clears of sediment.
- Check pressure and ampsThe installer confirms the pump builds pressure, shuts off at the switch setting and draws a normal current for its nameplate.
What decides how complicated it gets
| Factor | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Well depth | A deeper well means more pipe and cable to lift, and heavier loads. |
| Pipe type | Steel pipe is heavy and threaded; plastic pipe is lighter but can crack when handled badly. |
| Condition of wire | Old or nicked wire may be replaced, which adds material and time. |
| Access | Tight pump houses, basements or wells with limited headroom slow the work. |
| Stuck pump | Pumps held by scale, sand or a bent casing can need extra tools and effort. |
| Related parts | A failed pressure switch, tank or control box may be changed in the same visit. |
Safety before anyone starts
Never lean over an open well, and keep children and pets away. Heavy pipe under tension can swing or drop. Do not mix up the well cap's electrical parts with plumbing work.
After the new pump is in
Opening a well can let surface bacteria in. Ask the contractor whether they disinfect the well after the job. Shock chlorination is the usual method, and it is not a cure for ongoing contamination. Follow the instructions of your state health department or a source such as Penn State Extension.
Plan a bacteria test after the system has been flushed. Use a state-certified laboratory, and wait the period the lab or health department recommends after chlorinating.
Questions to settle before you hire
- Will the old drop pipe and wire be reused, and who decides?
- Is the pitless adapter and check valve being inspected?
- What warranty covers parts and labor?
- Who flushes and disinfects the well?
- What happens if the old pump will not come out?
Signs the pump itself has failed
A pro will want to rule out cheaper causes first. The pump may be fine when the problem is a tripped breaker, a failed pressure switch, a waterlogged tank or a bad capacitor. These checks are part of any honest diagnosis.
- No water at all, with the breaker on and the pressure switch clicking: the pump or its wire may be dead.
- Water that spits air or runs weakly: the well may be pumping low, or the pipe may be leaking.
- A pump that runs but never builds pressure: the check valve, a pipe leak or a worn pump may be the cause.
- A breaker that trips every time the pump starts: a motor, wire or capacitor fault may be present.
See our pages on pump motors that will not start and on repair versus replacement for the full decision path.
What to prepare before the crew arrives
- Clear the path to the wellhead and the pump house or basement area.
- Find the well log or any paperwork from the original install, including depth and pump specs.
- Note the age of the pump and what symptoms you saw.
- Take a photo of the pressure tank, switch and any control box labels.
- Plan for the water to be off for part of the day.
Having this information ready speeds up the visit and helps the contractor size the new pump.
How long the water is off
Most owners are without water for a part of a day, but wells with problems can take longer. Keep drinking water and some water for flushing toilets on hand. If the job drags on, ask what is causing the delay and what the next step is.
Common surprises
| Finding | Likely response |
|---|---|
| Corroded or leaking drop pipe | Replace the affected pipe sections. |
| Cracked insulation on the wire | Replace the cable or the damaged length. |
| Heavy scale or sand on the pump | Ask about well condition and cleaning or rehab options. |
| Worn pitless adapter or seal | Replace the adapter or seals before closing up. |
| Pump set too deep or too shallow | Reset to the right depth for the water level. |
Ask the crew to show you the old pump and any damaged parts. What they find helps you judge whether the well itself needs attention.
Questions people ask
How easy is it to replace a well pump?
On a shallow well it can be a straightforward job for a skilled person, but most submersible pumps sit deep and need lifting equipment. Wiring and well safety add risk, so most owners hire a licensed well contractor.
Do I need to replace the pressure tank with the pump?
Not always. The tank can be tested for pre-charge and a failed bladder. A pro may suggest replacing it if it is waterlogged or leaking.
Is the water safe right after a pump replacement?
Not automatically. Opening the well can let in bacteria. Flush the system, ask about disinfection, and test with a certified lab before drinking untreated.
Sources
- NGWA: WellOwner.org
- Minnesota Dept. of Health: Well Disinfection
- Penn State Extension: Shock Chlorination of Wells and Springs
- EPA: Private Drinking Water Wells
This page explains general practice for US private wells. Check your state's rules on the state pages, use a certified lab for testing, and hire a licensed well contractor for electrical or well work. See our editorial policy.
Still not sure what to do?
Ask us about your situation. A real person reads every question.
Thanks, we have your question.
We read every message and reply by email, usually within a few working days. If it is urgent (sickness, a positive E. coli test, or a flooded well), use bottled water and call your county or state health department now.

