How Fayette County stands out in Indiana
- Very little surface water: lakes and rivers cover under 1% of the county, one of the lowest shares in Indiana.
- Small by area: 215 square miles of land, the 5th smallest of the 91 Indiana counties on this site.
- Lower-priced homes: a median owner-occupied value of $130,700, 8th lowest among 91 Indiana counties here.
- Older housing than most of Indiana: the median home was built in 1962, the 14th oldest of 91 counties.
Closest look-alike: Union County next door. Compared with it, Fayette County has more people estimated on high-arsenic wells (131 vs 78), homes 8 years older by median year built and median home values $42,800 lower.
Closest match further away: Vanderburgh County elsewhere in Indiana. Next to it, Fayette County has median home values $53,300 lower, homes 8 years older by median year built and fewer people estimated on high-arsenic wells (131 vs 151).
Shallow wells in Fayette County
| Household well records | 1,148 |
|---|---|
| Median depth | 69 ft |
| Middle half of wells | 45 ft to 100 ft |
| Shallowest 10% / deepest 10% | under 34 ft / over 140 ft |
| Median static water level | 20 ft |
| Median tested yield | 10 gpm |
| Rank in Indiana (deepest = 1) | 77th of 91 |
| Deeper than this share of US counties in our data | 8% |
Most wells with a recorded depth fall under 100 ft (74%). Only 0% reach 500 ft or more.
Between the median water level and the median depth sit about 49 ft of water, roughly 72 gallons in a 6-inch casing.
The median tested yield is 10 gallons per minute.
A 69 ft well is cheap to drill
Shallow wells keep drilling costs down. At $25 to $65 a foot (Angi 2026 cost guide), reaching Fayette County's median of 69 ft costs about $1,700 to $4,500 for the hole itself.
That is small next to local house prices: under 3% of the median home value of $130,700 (Census ACS 2020–2024).
With water only 20 ft down, some homes can use a shallow-well jet pump, which lifts water about 25 feet at most; the rest need a submersible. See pump sizing.
Water quality in Fayette County
Public sampling data for Fayette County is thin (fewer than 10 wells with recent results), so the arsenic model below is the best county-level guide.
Arsenic estimate
The USGS arsenic model puts about 131 Fayette County residents (range 109 to 159) on household wells above 10 µg/L, lower than most Indiana counties. That is more than in about 32% of Indiana counties. USGS model estimate.
What to test for in Fayette County
- Coliform bacteria and nitrate every year; 74% of wells here are under 100 ft deep.
- Arsenic: USGS estimates about 131 people here drink from household wells above the 10 µg/L limit.
Buying an older home with a well in Fayette County
- The median home in Fayette County was built in 1962. Older homes often have older wells, so ask when the well was drilled and whether the casing, cap and pump have been replaced.
- Most wells here are between 45 ft and 100 ft. A shallow well near a septic field or barnyard needs a bacteria test before closing.
- Ask for a flow or yield test and compare it with the county median of 10 gallons per minute.
- Book a well inspection as well as a water test; they check different things.
What lies beneath Fayette County
Most of Fayette County (82%) lies outside any USGS principal aquifer, so wells draw on smaller, local water-bearing rock; the rest is over the Silurian-Devonian aquifers.
Uppermost principal aquifer: USGS Principal Aquifers map, sampled across the county on a grid. A well can draw from a deeper or local aquifer instead.
Fayette County next to its neighbours
3 of 5 neighbouring counties with records drill deeper. Medians nearby run from Franklin County (63 ft) to Henry County (88 ft).
| County | Median depth | Water level | Yield | People on high-arsenic wells (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fayette County | 69 ft | 20 ft | 10 gpm | 131 |
| Henry County | 88 ft | 30 ft | 20 gpm | 1,400 |
| Wayne County | 86 ft | 30 ft | 14 gpm | 518 |
| Rush County | 71 ft | 16 ft | 15 gpm | 814 |
| Union County | 65 ft | 18 ft | 10 gpm | 78 |
| Franklin County | 63 ft | 20 ft | 8 gpm | 118 |
Neighbours: Census county adjacency 2024.
Drilling over the decades in Fayette County
Drilling peaked early, in the 1970s, when 276 household wells were logged. Only 0% of dated records are from 2010 or later, so most wells in service are older.
Help in Indiana
For Fayette County well owners: Purdue University Extension, free or low-cost testing, and all Indiana well rules and data.
Questions about wells in Fayette County
How deep are wells in Fayette County, Indiana?
69 ft is the median across 1,148 household well records; the middle half are 45 ft to 100 ft.
Are wells in Fayette County deeper than elsewhere in Indiana?
No, they are shallower: Fayette County ranks deeper than about 15% of Indiana counties in our data, and deeper than 8% of US counties we cover.
How old are homes in Fayette County?
The Census median year built for Fayette County homes is 1962; it covers all homes, not only those on wells.
How far down is the water in Fayette County wells?
Driller logs put the median static water level at 20 ft below ground.
Data for Fayette County
1,148 household well records, dated from the 1950s to the 2000s, from the state well records (source); homes and population from Census ACS 2020–2024. How we filter the records. Download Fayette County as JSON (CC BY 4.0).
