How Butler County stands out in Pennsylvania
- Newer housing than most of Pennsylvania: the median home was built in 1980, the 4th newest of 67 counties.
- Higher-priced homes: a median owner-occupied value of $294,200, 9th highest among 67 Pennsylvania counties here.
- A deep driller archive: 9,749 household well records, 9th most of 67 Pennsylvania counties.
Closest look-alike: Lawrence County next door. Compared with it, Butler County has homes 23 years newer by median year built, median home values $147,000 higher and more people estimated on high-arsenic wells (1,519 vs 1,011).
Closest match further away: Union County elsewhere in Pennsylvania. Next to it, Butler County has more people estimated on high-arsenic wells (1,519 vs 402), homes 6 years newer by median year built and median home values $54,100 higher.
Wells in Butler County are shallower than most of Pennsylvania
| Household well records | 9,749 |
|---|---|
| Median depth | 148 ft |
| Middle half of wells | 105 ft to 208 ft |
| Shallowest 10% / deepest 10% | under 80 ft / over 290 ft |
| Median tested yield | 15 gpm |
| Rank in Pennsylvania (deepest = 1) | 46th of 67 |
| Deeper than this share of US counties in our data | 49% |
Most wells with a recorded depth fall 100 to 300 ft (71%). Only 0% reach 500 ft or more.
Wells here are productive, with a median tested yield of 15 gallons per minute, more than in about 91% of Pennsylvania counties.
Water quality in Butler County
Public sampling data for Butler County is thin (fewer than 10 wells with recent results), so the arsenic model below is the best county-level guide.
Arsenic estimate
About 1,519 people in Butler County (range 1,253 to 1,857) are estimated by USGS to be on household wells above the 10 µg/L arsenic limit, a middling figure for Pennsylvania. That is more than in about 78% of Pennsylvania counties. USGS model estimate.
What to test for in Butler County
- Coliform bacteria and nitrate once a year, the EPA baseline for any private well.
- Arsenic: USGS estimates about 1,519 people here drink from household wells above the 10 µg/L limit.
Butler County and the Pennsylvanian aquifers
All or nearly all of Butler County sits over the Pennsylvanian aquifers (sandstone aquifers), the uppermost principal aquifer USGS maps here. Among the 97 counties in our data that sit mainly over the same aquifer (across 5 states), Butler County's median well of 148 ft is deeper than most: deeper than about 78% of them.
Uppermost principal aquifer: USGS Principal Aquifers map, sampled across the county on a grid. A well can draw from a deeper or local aquifer instead.
What drilling to 148 ft costs in Butler County
Using $25 to $65 per foot for drilling only (Angi 2026 cost guide), a well at the median depth of 148 ft runs about $3,700 to $9,600.
That is small next to local house prices: under 3% of the median home value of $294,200 (Census ACS 2020–2024).
Equipment and permits come on top; our guide to drilling quotes shows what to ask Pennsylvania drillers to itemize.
Butler County next to its neighbours
Only 3 of 8 neighbouring counties with records have a deeper median well; nearby medians span from Clarion County (90 ft) to Beaver County (170 ft).
| County | Median depth | Water level | Yield | People on high-arsenic wells (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butler County | 148 ft | no data | 15 gpm | 1,519 |
| Beaver County | 170 ft | no data | 6 gpm | 773 |
| Allegheny County | 160 ft | no data | 7 gpm | 1,040 |
| Westmoreland County | 160 ft | no data | 5 gpm | 522 |
| Lawrence County | 137 ft | no data | 15 gpm | 1,011 |
| Armstrong County | 132 ft | no data | 6 gpm | 354 |
| Venango County | 100 ft | no data | 18 gpm | 742 |
| Mercer County | 95 ft | no data | 20 gpm | 4,108 |
| Clarion County | 90 ft | no data | 10 gpm | 261 |
Neighbours: Census county adjacency 2024.
Buying a home with a well in Butler County
- The median home here was built in 1980. Ask the seller for the well log, or look it up in Pennsylvania DCNR PaGWIS water wells.
- A well between 105 ft and 208 ft is normal for Butler County. Much shallower than 105 ft deserves a careful water test.
- A flow test should be routine; county wells are productive, with a median of 15 gallons per minute.
- Book a well inspection as well as a water test; they check different things.
Help in Pennsylvania
For Butler County well owners: Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, certified labs in Pennsylvania, free or low-cost testing, and all Pennsylvania well rules and data.
Questions about wells in Butler County
What is the average well depth in Butler County, Pennsylvania?
148 ft is the median across 9,749 household well records; the middle half are 105 ft to 208 ft.
How much water does a Butler County well produce?
The median tested yield is 15 gallons per minute, high for the state.
What aquifer do wells in Butler County draw from?
All or nearly all of Butler County sits over the Pennsylvanian aquifers (sandstone aquifers), the uppermost principal aquifer USGS maps here. Your own well log names the formation your well actually taps.
Is well water safe to drink in Butler County?
Arsenic is the main known risk, with about 1,519 people estimated on high-arsenic wells. Only a certified lab test of your own well can say.
Are wells in Butler County deeper than elsewhere in Pennsylvania?
No, they are shallower: Butler County ranks deeper than about 31% of Pennsylvania counties in our data, and deeper than 49% of US counties we cover.
Data for Butler County
9,749 household well records, from Pennsylvania DCNR PaGWIS water wells (source); homes and population from Census ACS 2020–2024. How we filter the records. Download Butler County as JSON (CC BY 4.0).
