Ask a question

Catalytic carbon vs regular carbon: what is the difference?

4 min readBy Updated Sources checked5 sources
Kitchen faucet running water into the sink
Photo: Unsplash
Short answerCatalytic carbon is treated activated carbon that speeds up certain reactions, so it can break down hydrogen sulfide and chloramine better than regular carbon. Regular carbon mainly adsorbs chlorine, tastes and some chemicals. Both need pre-filtration, and neither replaces disinfection or testing.

Key facts

What makes carbon catalytic

Regular activated carbon works by adsorption: contaminants stick to its surface. Catalytic carbon is treated so its surface also speeds up chemical reactions. It can help convert certain compounds into forms that are easier to remove.

Two common uses are hydrogen sulfide, the rotten-egg smell, and chloramine, a disinfectant some public systems use. For well owners, hydrogen sulfide is the main reason people look at catalytic carbon.

Side by side

Regular and catalytic carbon
FeatureRegular activated carbonCatalytic carbon
Main actionAdsorbs chlorine, tastes, odors, some chemicalsAdsorbs plus speeds reactions
Hydrogen sulfideLimitedMay help at low levels
ChloramineSlow and limitedBetter suited
Iron and manganeseNot designed for it; can foulMay be affected; heavy loads cause trouble
Needs pre-filterYesYes
BackwashOften in tank systemsOften, to clean the bed

Using catalytic carbon for rotten-egg smell

Hydrogen sulfide in well water often comes from sulfur bacteria or natural geology. Penn State Extension and the Minnesota Department of Health describe treatment options, and the right one depends on the concentration. Catalytic carbon can be part of the answer at low levels. Higher levels usually need oxidation and filtration.

Penn State also notes that catalytic carbon may need dissolved oxygen of at least 4.0 mg/L, and some groundwater needs pre-treatment to reach that. That is one reason to have a pro look at the design instead of buying a tank off a shelf.

What it does not fix

  • Bacteria and sulfur bacteria colonies in the well or pipes. If sulfur bacteria are the cause, the well and plumbing may need disinfection.
  • Hardness.
  • Nitrate and arsenic.
  • Heavy iron and manganese loads.
TipA rotten-egg smell only at the hot tap often points to the water heater, not the well. Check that first. A plumber or water heater pro can help.

How to decide

  1. Find out where the smell startsCheck cold water, hot water and each fixture. Smell at the hot tap only suggests the water heater.
  2. Test the waterAsk a certified lab about hydrogen sulfide, iron, manganese, pH and bacteria.
  3. Compare optionsCatalytic carbon for low levels; oxidation and filtration for higher levels.
  4. Plan pre-treatmentSediment filtration first. Iron and manganese treatment if needed.
  5. Check the wellSulfur bacteria in the well may need disinfection.
  6. RetestCheck the smell and the lab results after install.

Upkeep and cost

Where regular carbon is the better pick

If your water has chlorine taste from a chlorination system, or musty or earthy tastes, regular activated carbon is usually enough. It costs less and is simpler to set up. Using catalytic carbon for a simple taste problem adds expense without benefit.

Regular carbon in a tank also needs a pre-filter and eventual replacement. If your water carries sediment, the carbon can clog and channel, which lets water bypass the bed.

Where catalytic carbon is the better pick

Catalytic carbon is aimed at hydrogen sulfide and chloramine problems, where regular carbon is quickly used up. Because it is built for reaction rather than only adsorption, it can last longer in those jobs. It still needs the right water chemistry, and that is where installers earn their fee.

If you have a strong rotten-egg smell, do not assume catalytic carbon will fix it. The Minnesota Department of Health and Penn State describe causes and treatment options, and a stronger smell often calls for oxidation followed by filtration.

What to ask the installer

  • What hydrogen sulfide level is this design meant for?
  • Does my water have enough dissolved oxygen, or does it need pre-treatment?
  • How often will it need backwashing, and how much water does that use?
  • What do I replace, and when?
  • Will my iron and manganese damage the bed?

Ask for the answers in writing, and retest the water after the system has been running for a few weeks.

Catalytic carbon needs backwashing and eventual replacement. The life depends on water chemistry, flow and loading. Ask the installer what to expect and keep a log of service dates.

Why the smell may come back

If the rotten-egg smell returns after a few weeks or months, common causes include a bed that is used up, a flow rate that is too high for the bed size, hydrogen sulfide levels higher than the design expected, or sulfur bacteria growing in the well or plumbing. Each has a different fix, so do not just replace the carbon without checking.

Sulfur bacteria can be treated by disinfecting the well and plumbing. A licensed well contractor can advise. If the smell is also present in the hot water only, check the water heater, because a magnesium anode rod in some heaters can feed sulfate-reducing bacteria. A plumber can advise on that.

Do not forget the basics

Even when the smell is fixed, test for bacteria and nitrate every year. Hydrogen sulfide itself is mainly a nuisance, but the conditions that make it can be associated with other water issues. A routine test is cheap compared with guessing.

Keep the lab report, the installer's design notes and service dates in one folder. When you sell the house, buyers and inspectors will ask.

We do not quote a price. Costs vary by tank size, flow and region, so get at least two local quotes.

SafetySwitch off power at the breaker before servicing control valves or pumps. If you are unsure, hire a licensed pro.

Questions people ask

Is catalytic carbon better than regular carbon for well water?

It is better for specific jobs such as hydrogen sulfide and chloramine. Regular carbon is fine for chlorine and many tastes and odors.

Will catalytic carbon remove iron?

It is not designed for heavy iron, and iron can foul it. Treat iron with oxidation and filtration first.

Does catalytic carbon need backwashing?

Typically yes, to loosen and clean the bed. Your installer should set up the schedule.

Can catalytic carbon fix sulfur smell completely?

At low levels it may. Higher levels usually need other treatment. Test and ask a pro.

Sources

This page explains general practice for US private wells. Check your state's rules on the state pages, use a certified lab for testing, and hire a licensed well contractor for electrical or well work. See our editorial policy.

Still not sure what to do?

Ask us about your situation. A real person reads every question.

This field is required.
We reply by email. We never share it without your permission.Enter an email address like name@example.com.
Describe what you are seeing and anything you have tried. Plain words are fine.Please write at least 20 characters so we can help.
Choose your state so we can point you to the right rules.
Prefer the full form?

Thanks, we have your question.

We read every message and reply by email, usually within a few working days. If it is urgent (sickness, a positive E. coli test, or a flooded well), use bottled water and call your county or state health department now.

Find your state's well program

Keep reading

Related guides

All 29 water treatment guides