Ask a question

Shallow well vs deep well

4 min readBy Updated Sources checked3 sources
Old wooden well with a bucket and a trough
Photo: Unsplash
Short answerShallow wells draw groundwater close to the surface, so they are more exposed to runoff, septic systems and dry spells. Deep wells reach water farther down, behind more soil and rock, and often have steadier supply and lower bacteria risk. Neither is automatically safe. Both need yearly testing, a sealed cap and good construction.

Key facts

No fixed line between shallow and deep

People call a well shallow or deep without a standard cutoff. The terms describe how close the water source is to the surface and how much natural material lies between you and possible contamination. A dug well or a driven well in sandy soil is usually shallow. A drilled well that taps bedrock or a confined aquifer is usually deeper.

Depth is only part of the picture. Construction quality, casing depth, the type of aquifer and what's happening on the land nearby all matter. A well record gives the real numbers, and many states publish well records online. Our state pages list where.

How they compare

Shallow and deep wells compared
FeatureShallow wellDeep well
Water sourceShallow groundwater, often unconfinedDeeper aquifer, often under rock or clay layers
Exposure to runoff and septicHigherUsually lower, if well sealed
Dry-spell riskHigher, since the water table falls firstUsually lower
Typical pumpOften a jet pump at the surfaceOften a submersible pump in the well
Natural mineralsVaries, may carry nitrate from land useVaries, may carry iron, manganese, arsenic or radon depending on geology
Cost to buildLowerHigher
Seal and casing importanceHighHigh

These are general patterns, not rules. A deep well with a failed seal can be contaminated, and a shallow well in a clean area can test clean year after year.

Water quality: what to test for

In both cases, test at least once a year for total coliform bacteria and nitrate, and after flooding, repairs or any change in taste, smell or color. Use a state-certified lab. Beyond that, the right extra tests depend on local geology and land use. Shallow wells near farms or septic systems often warrant a closer look at nitrate and bacteria. Deeper bedrock wells in some areas may need testing for arsenic, uranium or radon.

Ask your state or county health department which contaminants are common near you. See also our pages on the contaminants that most often turn up in private wells.

Pump differences

A shallow well may use a jet pump at the surface. A deeper well usually needs a submersible pump set down in the well, because surface pumps can only lift water from a limited depth. If you are replacing a pump, a contractor will check the water level and well depth and choose the type that fits.

SafetyPumps and pressure switches run on household power, often 240 volts. Turn off the breaker before touching anything electrical. Hire a licensed pro if you are unsure.

Reliability in dry weather

The water table in shallow ground falls first in a drought. A well that goes dry in late summer may be too shallow for the area, or may have a pump set too high. A deeper well, or lowering the pump, can help. A contractor can tell you which is right after checking the water level. See our page on wells running dry.

Which is better for you?

If you are building, local geology and rules decide. A good driller picks a depth that reaches reliable, protected water. If you already have a shallow well, you can keep it safe with a sealed cap, grading, regular testing and good habits, and decide about a new, deeper well if problems keep happening.

Signs your shallow well is at risk

  • Water turns cloudy or changes after heavy rain or snowmelt.
  • Bacteria show up in tests, then clear, then return.
  • Nitrate is rising across yearly tests.
  • The well goes low in dry months.
  • Farm fields, septic systems, fuel tanks or livestock are close by.
  • The cap or lining is old, cracked or loose.

These are signs that surface water or land use is reaching the well. A contractor can inspect the well, and your health department can suggest tests. Fixes include a new cap, a better seal, grading, a liner, a deeper well or a different location.

Common myths

Deeper means cleaner. Not always. Deep water can carry natural minerals, and a poor seal can bring in surface water. Shallow means unsafe. Not necessarily. A well-sealed shallow well in a protected area may test clean. A neighbor's results apply to you. Not reliably. Wells a short distance apart can differ because the ground changes. Test your own water.

A well record tells you your well's depth and casing. If you don't have one, a contractor can find out.

Questions to ask your contractor

  1. How deep is my well, and how deep is the casing?
  2. What type of aquifer does it draw from?
  3. How close is the well to septic systems, fields and other risks?
  4. Is my pump the right type for the depth?
  5. Would a deeper well make sense here, and what would it reach?
  6. What should I test for in this area, beyond bacteria and nitrate?

Write the answers down and keep them with your well record. If you plan to buy property, ask the same questions about the well that comes with it. The answers set how much testing and upkeep you can expect, and whether upgrading is likely.

If you want one practical takeaway, it is this: don't judge a well by its depth alone. Look at the seal, the cap, the test results and the record, then decide whether the well needs changes. Depth is one piece of a larger picture, and the lab results and a licensed inspection will tell you more than any number.

Questions people ask

Is a deep well better than a shallow well?

Often it is more protected and more reliable, but not always. Construction quality, seal and local geology matter as much as depth.

Is shallow well water safe to drink?

It can be, if the well is sealed, the area is protected and you test regularly. Shallow wells are more exposed, so test at least once a year for bacteria and nitrate.

How deep is a shallow well?

There is no standard number. A well is called shallow if it draws water close to the surface. Your well record shows your actual depth.

Do deep wells need testing?

Yes. Deeper water can have natural contaminants such as arsenic or radon, and a failed seal can let bacteria in.

Sources

This page explains general practice for US private wells. Check your state's rules on the state pages, use a certified lab for testing, and hire a licensed well contractor for electrical or well work. See our editorial policy.

Still not sure what to do?

Ask us about your situation. A real person reads every question.

This field is required.
We reply by email. We never share it without your permission.Enter an email address like name@example.com.
Describe what you are seeing and anything you have tried. Plain words are fine.Please write at least 20 characters so we can help.
Choose your state so we can point you to the right rules.
Prefer the full form?

Thanks, we have your question.

We read every message and reply by email, usually within a few working days. If it is urgent (sickness, a positive E. coli test, or a flooded well), use bottled water and call your county or state health department now.

Find your state's well program

Keep reading

Related guides

All 29 the well itself guides