How Butler County stands out in Iowa
- A high share of owner-occupied homes (84%), 3rd highest in our Iowa set.
- Its deepest wells go less far than in most of Iowa: the deepest 10% start at 238 ft, 13th shallowest of 91.
- One of the most uniform well-depth patterns in Iowa: the middle half spans 125 ft to 200 ft.
Closest look-alike: Chickasaw County next door. Compared with it, Butler County has homes 8 years older by median year built and fewer people estimated on high-arsenic wells (198 vs 241).
Closest match further away: Greene County elsewhere in Iowa. Next to it, Butler County has fewer people estimated on high-arsenic wells (198 vs 504), homes 4 years newer by median year built and wells about 4 ft shallower at the median.
Iron is the one to test for in Butler County
Iron stands out in measured groundwater: 47% of 32 sampled wells were over the EPA SMCL.
| Substance | Wells tested | Over limit | Median | Limit used | Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arsenic | 25 | 0% | 0.5 µg/L | EPA MCL | 2001 to 2017 |
| Nitrate (as N) | 17 | 18% | 0.05 mg/L as N | EPA MCL | 1990 to 2017 |
| Manganese | 32 | 0% | 0.01 mg/L | EPA lifetime health advisory | 1990 to 2017 |
| Iron | 32 | 47% | 0.28 mg/L | EPA SMCL | 1990 to 2017 |
| Fluoride | 32 | 0% | 0.635 mg/L | EPA MCL | 1990 to 2017 |
| Lead | 25 | 0% | 0.5 µg/L | EPA action level | 2001 to 2017 |
| Hardness | 16 | no data | 252 mg/L as CaCO3 | over 180 mg/L is very hard | 1990 to 2017 |
Latest result per well since 1990, Water Quality Portal; 179 results across 7 substances.
Arsenic estimate
About 198 people in Butler County (range 150 to 262) are estimated by USGS to be on household wells above the 10 µg/L arsenic limit, a middling figure for Iowa. That is more than in about 43% of Iowa counties. USGS model estimate.
What to test for in Butler County
- Coliform bacteria and nitrate once a year, the EPA baseline for any private well.
- Arsenic: USGS estimates about 198 people here drink from household wells above the 10 µg/L limit.
- Iron: 47% of sampled wells here were over the EPA SMCL.
- Hardness if you are thinking about a softener (sampled median 252 mg/L).
Got results already? Check them with our result interpreter.
Wells in Butler County are shallower than most of Iowa
| Household well records | 448 |
|---|---|
| Median depth | 156 ft |
| Middle half of wells | 125 ft to 200 ft |
| Shallowest 10% / deepest 10% | under 97 ft / over 238 ft |
| Rank in Iowa (deepest = 1) | 72nd of 91 |
| Deeper than this share of US counties in our data | 53% |
Almost all wells with a recorded depth fall 100 to 300 ft (88%). Only 0% reach 500 ft or more.
Butler County and the Silurian-Devonian aquifers
All or nearly all of Butler County sits over the Silurian-Devonian aquifers (carbonate-rock aquifers), the uppermost principal aquifer USGS maps here. Among the 130 counties in our data that sit mainly over the same aquifer (across 7 states), Butler County's median well of 156 ft is deeper than most: deeper than about 76% of them.
Uppermost principal aquifer: USGS Principal Aquifers map, sampled across the county on a grid. A well can draw from a deeper or local aquifer instead.
What drilling to 156 ft costs in Butler County
Using $25 to $65 per foot for drilling only (Angi 2026 cost guide), a well at the median depth of 156 ft runs about $3,900 to $10,100.
Against a median home value of $165,400 (Census ACS 2020–2024), a new well at that depth is about 2% to 6% of a house's worth, before equipment.
Equipment and permits come on top; our guide to drilling quotes shows what to ask Iowa drillers to itemize.
Buying an older home with a well in Butler County
- The median home in Butler County was built in 1958. Older homes often have older wells, so ask when the well was drilled and whether the casing, cap and pump have been replaced.
- A well between 125 ft and 200 ft is normal for Butler County. Much shallower than 125 ft deserves a careful water test.
- Make sure the water test includes iron; 47% of sampled local wells were over its limit.
- Book a well inspection as well as a water test; they check different things.
Butler County next to its neighbours
5 of 8 neighbouring counties with records drill deeper. Medians nearby run from Bremer County (142 ft) to Cerro Gordo County (240 ft).
| County | Median depth | Water level | Yield | People on high-arsenic wells (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butler County | 156 ft | no data | no data | 198 |
| Cerro Gordo County | 240 ft | no data | no data | 634 |
| Grundy County | 200 ft | no data | no data | 679 |
| Floyd County | 195 ft | no data | no data | 213 |
| Black Hawk County | 165 ft | no data | no data | 280 |
| Hardin County | 160 ft | no data | no data | 733 |
| Chickasaw County | 156 ft | no data | no data | 241 |
| Franklin County | 150 ft | no data | no data | 351 |
| Bremer County | 142 ft | no data | no data | 300 |
Neighbours: Census county adjacency 2024.
Drilling over the decades in Butler County
Much of the drilling is recent: the busiest decade was the 2000s, with 175 household wells logged. 50% of dated records are from 2010 or later, a sign of steady new drilling.
Help in Iowa
For Butler County well owners: Iowa Department of Natural Resources, Private Well Program, certified labs in Iowa, free or low-cost testing, and all Iowa well rules and data.
Questions about wells in Butler County
What is the average well depth in Butler County, Iowa?
156 ft is the median across 448 household well records; the middle half are 125 ft to 200 ft.
Is well water safe to drink in Butler County?
Iron stands out in measured groundwater: 47% of 32 sampled wells were over the EPA SMCL. Arsenic is the main known risk, with about 198 people estimated on high-arsenic wells.
What aquifer do wells in Butler County draw from?
All or nearly all of Butler County sits over the Silurian-Devonian aquifers (carbonate-rock aquifers), the uppermost principal aquifer USGS maps here. Your own well log names the formation your well actually taps.
Are wells in Butler County deeper than elsewhere in Iowa?
No, they are shallower: Butler County ranks deeper than about 21% of Iowa counties in our data, and deeper than 53% of US counties we cover.
How old are homes in Butler County?
The Census median year built for Butler County homes is 1958; it covers all homes, not only those on wells.
Data for Butler County
448 household well records, dated from the 1990s to the 2020s, from the state well records (source); homes and population from Census ACS 2020–2024. How we filter the records. Download Butler County as JSON (CC BY 4.0).
