How Sullivan County stands out in New York
- Newer housing than most of New York: the median home was built in 1974, the 4th newest of 57 counties.
- A deep driller archive: 3,765 household well records, 8th most of 57 New York counties.
- Its deepest wells go further than in most of New York: the deepest 10% start at 528 ft, 9th deepest of 57.
- One of the most uniform well-depth patterns in New York: the middle half spans 235 ft to 420 ft.
Closest look-alike: Orange County next door. Compared with it, Sullivan County has fewer people estimated on high-arsenic wells (482 vs 1,660), median home values $138,900 lower and wells about 15 ft deeper at the median.
Closest match further away: Hamilton County elsewhere in New York. Next to it, Sullivan County has more people estimated on high-arsenic wells (482 vs 27), homes 5 years newer by median year built and wells about 5 ft deeper at the median.
Deep wells in Sullivan County
| Household well records | 3,765 |
|---|---|
| Median depth | 305 ft |
| Middle half of wells | 235 ft to 420 ft |
| Shallowest 10% / deepest 10% | under 180 ft / over 528 ft |
| Median tested yield | 8 gpm |
| Rank in New York (deepest = 1) | 8th of 57 |
| Deeper than this share of US counties in our data | 87% |
The largest group of wells with a recorded depth fall 300 to 500 ft (44%).
The median tested yield is 8 gallons per minute.
Deep wells make drilling in Sullivan County expensive
At 305 ft for a median well, depth drives the bill: $25 to $65 a foot (Angi 2026 cost guide) puts drilling alone at $7,600 to $19,800. A well as deep as the 75th percentile (420 ft) would be $10,500 to $27,300.
Against a median home value of $249,000 (Census ACS 2020–2024), a new well at that depth is about 3% to 8% of a house's worth, before equipment.
Equipment and permits come on top; our guide to drilling quotes shows what to ask New York drillers to itemize.
Sullivan County has deeper wells than every neighbour
None of its 5 neighbours with records has a deeper median well. The neighbours range from Wayne County (220 ft) to Orange County (290 ft).
| County | Median depth | Water level | Yield | People on high-arsenic wells (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sullivan County | 305 ft | no data | 8 gpm | 482 |
| Orange County | 290 ft | no data | 8 gpm | 1,660 |
| Delaware County | 274 ft | no data | 5 gpm | 421 |
| Ulster County | 270 ft | no data | 7 gpm | 950 |
| Pike County, PA | 260 ft | no data | 15 gpm | 206 |
| Wayne County, PA | 220 ft | no data | 15 gpm | 655 |
Neighbours: Census county adjacency 2024.
Water quality in Sullivan County
In measured groundwater samples, arsenic was the most common problem, with 6% of 17 tested wells over the EPA MCL.
| Substance | Wells tested | Over limit | Median | Limit used | Years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arsenic | 17 | 6% | 0.5 µg/L | EPA MCL | 2001 to 2020 |
| Nitrate (as N) | 17 | 0% | 0.228 mg/L as N | EPA MCL | 2001 to 2020 |
| Uranium | 17 | 0% | 0.448 µg/L | EPA MCL | 2001 to 2020 |
| Manganese | 17 | 6% | 0.0057 mg/L | EPA lifetime health advisory | 2001 to 2020 |
| Iron | 17 | 0% | 0.0242 mg/L | EPA SMCL | 2001 to 2020 |
| Fluoride | 17 | 0% | 0.07 mg/L | EPA MCL | 2001 to 2020 |
| Lead | 17 | 0% | 0.25 µg/L | EPA action level | 2001 to 2020 |
| Radon | 17 | 6% | 1570 pCi/L | EPA AMCL | 2001 to 2020 |
| Hardness | 17 | no data | 56 mg/L as CaCO3 | over 180 mg/L is very hard | 2001 to 2020 |
Latest result per well since 1990, Water Quality Portal; 153 results across 9 substances.
Arsenic estimate
The USGS arsenic model puts about 482 Sullivan County residents (range 392 to 599) on household wells above 10 µg/L, lower than most New York counties. That is more than in about 37% of New York counties. USGS model estimate.
What to test for in Sullivan County
- Coliform bacteria and nitrate every year even in wells this deep (305 ft median); bacteria get in through a cracked cap or casing, not only through the aquifer.
- Arsenic: USGS estimates about 482 people here drink from household wells above the 10 µg/L limit.
- Manganese: 6% of sampled wells here were over the EPA lifetime health advisory.
- Radon: 6% of sampled wells here were over the EPA AMCL.
Got results already? Check them with our result interpreter.
What lies beneath Sullivan County
Most of Sullivan County (100%) lies outside any USGS principal aquifer, so wells draw on smaller, local water-bearing rock.
Uppermost principal aquifer: USGS Principal Aquifers map, sampled across the county on a grid. A well can draw from a deeper or local aquifer instead.
Buying a home with a well in Sullivan County
- The median home here was built in 1974. Ask the seller for the well log, or look it up in the state well records.
- Wells here commonly run 235 ft to 420 ft. If the log shows a much shallower well, ask the inspector why.
- Ask for a flow or yield test and compare it with the county median of 8 gallons per minute.
- Make sure the water test includes arsenic; 6% of sampled local wells were over its limit.
Help in New York
For Sullivan County well owners: New York State Department of Health, certified labs in New York, free or low-cost testing, and all New York well rules and data.
Questions about wells in Sullivan County
How deep do you have to drill for water in Sullivan County, New York?
305 ft is the median across 3,765 household well records; the middle half are 235 ft to 420 ft.
Are wells in Sullivan County deeper than elsewhere in New York?
Yes: Sullivan County ranks deeper than about 86% of New York counties in our data, and deeper than 87% of US counties we cover.
What would a new well in Sullivan County cost to drill?
Roughly $7,600 to $19,800 for the drilling at the median depth of 305 ft, before the pump and pressure tank.
Is well water safe to drink in Sullivan County?
In measured groundwater samples, arsenic was the most common problem, with 6% of 17 tested wells over the EPA MCL. Arsenic is the main known risk, with about 482 people estimated on high-arsenic wells.
Data for Sullivan County
3,765 household well records, from the state well records (source); homes and population from Census ACS 2020–2024. How we filter the records. Download Sullivan County as JSON (CC BY 4.0).
